Littérature scientifique sur le sujet « Autonomous Driving Systems »

Nowadays, autonomous driving revolution is getting closer to reality. To achieve the Autonomous driving the first step is to develop the Advanced Driver Assistance System (ADAS). Driver-assistance systems are one of the fastest-growing segments in automotive electronics since already there are many forms of ADAS available. To investigate state of art of development of ADAS towards Autonomous Driving, we develop Systematic Mapping Study (SMS). SMS methodology is used to collect, classify, and analyze the relevant publications. A classification is introduced based on the developments carried out in ADAS towards Autonomous driving. According to SMS methodology, we identified 894 relevant publications about ADAS and its developmental journey toward Autonomous Driving completed from 2012 to 2016. We classify the area of our research under three classifications: technical classifications, research types and research contributions. The related publications are classified under thirty-three technical classifications. This thesis sheds light on a better understanding of the achievements and shortcomings in this area. By evaluating collected results, we answer our seven research questions. The result specifies that most of the publications belong to the Models and Solution Proposal from the research type and contribution. The least number of the publications belong to the Automated…Autonomous driving from the technical classification which indicated the lack of publications in this area.

L’anotació manual d’imatges per desenvolupar sistemes basats en visió per computador ha estat un dels punts més problemàtics des que s’utilitza aprenentatge automàtic per a això. Aquesta tesi es centra en aprofitar les dades sintètiques per alleujar el cost de les anotacions manuals en tres tasques de percepció relacionades amb l’assistència a la conducció i la conducció autònoma. En tot moment assumim l’ús de xarxes neuronals convolucionals per al desenvolupament dels nostres models profunds de percepció. La primera tasca planteja el reconeixement de senyals de trànsit, un problema de classificació d’imatges. Assumim que el nombre de classes de senyals de trànsit a reconèixer s’ha d’incrementar sense haver pogut anotar noves imatges amb què realitzar el corresponent reentrenament. Demostrem que aprofitant les dades sintètiques de les noves classes i transformant-les amb una xarxa adversària-generativa (GAN, de les seves sigles en anglès) entrenada amb les classes conegudes (sense usar mostres de les noves classes), és possible reentrenar la xarxa neuronal per classificar tots els senyals en una proporció ~1/4 entre classes noves i conegudes. La segona tasca consisteix en la detecció de vehicles i vianants (objectes) en imatges. En aquest cas, assumim la recepció d’un conjunt d’imatges sense anotar. L’objectiu és anotar automàticament aquestes imatges perquè així es puguin utilitzar posteriorment en l’entrenament del detector d’objectes que desitgem. Per assolir aquest objectiu, vam partir de dades sintètiques anotades i proposem un mètode d’aprenentatge semi-supervisat basat en la idea del co-aprenentatge. A més, utilitzem una GAN per reduir la distància entre els dominis sintètic i real abans d’aplicar el co-aprenentatge. Els nostres resultats quantitatius mostren que el procediment desenvolupat permet anotar el conjunt d’imatges d’entrada amb la precisió suficient per entrenar detectors d’objectes de forma efectiva; és a dir, tan precisos com si les imatges s’haguessin anotat manualment. A la tercera tasca deixem enrere l’espai 2D de les imatges, i ens centrem en processar núvols de punts 3D provinents de sensors LiDAR. El nostre objectiu inicial era desenvolupar un detector d’objectes 3D (vehicles, vianants, ciclistes) entrenat en núvols de punts sintètics estil LiDAR. En el cas de les imatges es podia esperar el problema de canvi de domini degut a les diferències visuals entre les imatges sintètiques i reals. Però, a priori, no esperàvem el mateix en treballar amb núvols de punts LiDAR, ja que es tracta d’informació geomètrica provinent del mostreig actiu del món, sense que l’aparença visual influeixi. No obstant això, a la pràctica, hem vist que també apareixen els problemes d’adaptació de domini. Factors com els paràmetres de mostreig del LiDAR, la configuració dels sensors a bord del vehicle autònom, i l’anotació manual dels objectes 3D, indueixen diferències de domini. A la tesi demostrem aquesta observació mitjançant un exhaustiu conjunt d’experiments amb diferents bases de dades públiques i detectors 3D disponibles. Per tant, en relació amb la tercera tasca, el treball s’ha centrat finalment en el disseny d’una GAN capaç de transformar núvols de punts 3D per portar-los d’un domini a un altre, un tema relativament inexplorat.Finalment, cal esmentar que tots els conjunts de dades sintètiques usats en aquestes tres tasques han estat dissenyats i generats en el context d’aquesta tesi doctoral i es faran públics. En general, considerem que aquesta tesi presenta un avanç en el foment de la utilització de dades sintètiques per al desenvolupament de models profunds de percepció, essencials en el camp de la conducció autònoma.<br>La anotación manual de imágenes para desarrollar sistemas basados en visión por computador ha sido uno de los puntos más problemáticos desde que se utiliza aprendizaje automático para ello. Esta tesis se centra en aprovechar los datos sintéticos para aliviar el coste de las anotaciones manuales en tres tareas de percepción relacionadas con la asistencia a la conducción y la conducción autónoma. En todo momento asumimos el uso de redes neuronales convolucionales para el desarrollo de nuestros modelos profundos de percepción. La primera tarea plantea el reconocimiento de señales de tráfico, un problema de clasificación de imágenes. Asumimos que el número de clases de señales de tráfico a reconocer se debe incrementar sin haber podido anotar nuevas imágenes con las que realizar el correspondiente reentrenamiento. Demostramos que aprovechando los datos sintéticos de las nuevas clases y transformándolas con una red adversaria-generativa (GAN, de sus siglas en inglés) entrenada con las clases conocidas (sin usar muestras de las nuevas clases), es posible reentrenar la red neuronal para clasificar todas las señales en una proporción de ~1/4 entre clases nuevas y conocidas. La segunda tarea consiste en la detección de vehículos y peatones (objetos) en imágenes. En este caso, asumimos la recepción de un conjunto de imágenes sin anotar. El objetivo es anotar automáticamente esas imágenes para que así se puedan utilizar posteriormente en el entrenamiento del detector de objetos que deseemos. Para alcanzar este objetivo, partimos de datos sintéticos anotados y proponemos un método de aprendizaje semi-supervisado basado en la idea del co-aprendizaje. Además, utilizamos una GAN para reducir la distancia entre los dominios sintético y real antes de aplicar el co-aprendizaje. Nuestros resultados cuantitativos muestran que el procedimiento desarrollado permite anotar el conjunto de imágenes de entrada con la precisión suficiente para entrenar detectores de objetos de forma efectiva; es decir, tan precisos como si las imágenes se hubiesen anotado manualmente. En la tercera tarea dejamos atrás el espacio 2D de las imágenes, y nos centramos en procesar nubes de puntos 3D provenientes de sensores LiDAR. Nuestro objetivo inicial era desarrollar un detector de objetos 3D (vehículos, peatones, ciclistas) entrenado en nubes de puntos sintéticos estilo LiDAR. En el caso de las imágenes cabía esperar el problema de cambio de dominio debido a las diferencias visuales entre las imágenes sintéticas y reales. Pero, a priori, no esperábamos lo mismo al trabajar con nubes de puntos LiDAR, ya que se trata de información geométrica proveniente del muestreo activo del mundo, sin que la apariencia visual influya. Sin embargo, en la práctica, hemos visto que también aparecen los problemas de adaptación de dominio. Factores como los parámetros de muestreo del LiDAR, la configuración de los sensores a bordo del vehículo autónomo, y la anotación manual de los objetos 3D, inducen diferencias de dominio. En la tesis demostramos esta observación mediante un exhaustivo conjunto de experimentos con diferentes bases de datos públicas y detectores 3D disponibles. Por tanto, en relación a la tercera tarea, el trabajo se ha centrado finalmente en el diseño de una GAN capaz de transformar nubes de puntos 3D para llevarlas de un dominio a otro, un tema relativamente inexplorado. Finalmente, cabe mencionar que todos los conjuntos de datos sintéticos usados en estas tres tareas han sido diseñados y generados en el contexto de esta tesis doctoral y se harán públicos. En general, consideramos que esta tesis presenta un avance en el fomento de la utilización de datos sintéticos para el desarrollo de modelos profundos de percepción, esenciales en el campo de la conducción autónoma.<br>Manually annotating images to develop vision models has been a major bottleneck since computer vision and machine learning started to walk together. This thesis focuses on leveraging synthetic data to alleviate manual annotation for three perception tasks related to driving assistance and autonomous driving. In all cases, we assume the use of deep convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to develop our perception models. The first task addresses traffic sign recognition (TSR), a kind of multi-class classification problem. We assume that the number of sign classes to be recognized must be suddenly increased without having annotated samples to perform the corresponding TSR CNN re-training. We show that leveraging synthetic samples of such new classes and transforming them by a generative adversarial network (GAN) trained on the known classes (i.e., without using samples from the new classes), it is possible to re-train the TSR CNN to properly classify all the signs for a ~1/4 ratio of new/known sign classes. The second task addresses on-board 2D object detection, focusing on vehicles and pedestrians. In this case, we assume that we receive a set of images without the annotations required to train an object detector, i.e., without object bounding boxes. Therefore, our goal is to self-annotate these images so that they can later be used to train the desired object detector. In order to reach this goal, we leverage from synthetic data and propose a semi-supervised learning approach based on the co-training idea. In fact, we use a GAN to reduce the synth-to-real domain shift before applying co-training. Our quantitative results show that co-training and GAN-based image-to-image translation complement each other up to allow the training of object detectors without manual annotation, and still almost reaching the upper-bound performances of the detectors trained from human annotations. While in previous tasks we focus on vision-based perception, the third task we address focuses on LiDAR pointclouds. Our initial goal was to develop a 3D object detector trained on synthetic LiDAR-style pointclouds. While for images we may expect synth/real-to-real domain shift due to differences in their appearance (e.g. when source and target images come from different camera sensors), we did not expect so for LiDAR pointclouds since these active sensors factor out appearance and provide sampled shapes. However, in practice, we have seen that it can be domain shift even among real-world LiDAR pointclouds. Factors such as the sampling parameters of the LiDARs, the sensor suite configuration on-board the ego-vehicle, and the human annotation of 3D bounding boxes, do induce a domain shift. We show it through comprehensive experiments with different publicly available datasets and 3D detectors. This redirected our goal towards the design of a GAN for pointcloud-to-pointcloud translation, a relatively unexplored topic. Finally, it is worth to mention that all the synthetic datasets used for these three tasks, have been designed and generated in the context of this PhD work and will be publicly released. Overall, we think this PhD presents several steps forward to encourage leveraging synthetic data for developing deep perception models in the field of driving assistance and autonomous driving.<br>Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona. Programa de Doctorat en Informàtica

For safe mobility, an autonomous vehicle must perceive the surroundings accurately. There are many perception tasks associated with understanding the local environment such as object detection, localization, and lane analysis. Object detection, in particular, plays a vital role in determining an object’s location and classifying it correctly and is one of the challenging tasks in the self-driving research area. Before employing an object detection module in autonomous vehicle testing, an organization needs to have a precise analysis of the module. Hence, it becomes crucial for a company to have an evaluation framework to evaluate an object detection algorithm’s performance. This thesis develops a comprehensive framework for evaluating and analyzing object detection algorithms, both 2D (camera images based) and 3D (LiDAR point cloud-based). The pipeline developed in this thesis provides the ability to evaluate multiple models with ease, signified by the key performance metrics, Average Precision, F-score, and Mean Average Precision. 40-point interpolation method is used to calculate the Average Precision.<br>För säker rörlighet måste ett autonomt fordon uppfatta omgivningen exakt. Det finns många uppfattningsuppgifter associerade med att förstå den lokala miljön, såsom objektdetektering, lokalisering och filanalys. I synnerhet objektdetektering spelar en viktig roll för att bestämma ett objekts plats och klassificera det korrekt och är en av de utmanande uppgifterna inom det självdrivande forskningsområdet. Innan en anställd detekteringsmodul används i autonoma fordonsprovningar måste en organisation ha en exakt analys av modulen. Därför blir det avgörande för ett företag att ha en utvärderingsram för att utvärdera en objektdetekteringsalgoritms prestanda. Denna avhandling utvecklar ett omfattande ramverk för utvärdering och analys av objektdetekteringsalgoritmer, både 2 D (kamerabilder baserade) och 3 D (LiDAR-punktmolnbaserade). Rörledningen som utvecklats i denna avhandling ger möjlighet att enkelt utvärdera flera modeller, betecknad med nyckelprestandamätvärdena, Genomsnittlig precision, F-poäng och genomsnittlig genomsnittlig precision. 40-punkts interpoleringsmetod används för att beräkna medelprecisionen.

The increasing usage of electronics and software in a modern automobile enables realization of many advanced features. One such feature is autonomous driving. Autonomous driving means that a human driver’s intervention is not required to drive the automobile; rather, theautomobile is capable of driving itself. Achieving automobile autonomyrequires research in several areas, one of which is the area of automotive electrical/electronics (E/E) architectures. These architectures deal with the design of the computer hardware and software present inside various subsystems of the vehicle, with particular attention to their interaction and modularization. The aim of this thesis is to investigate how automotive E/E architectures should be designed so that 1) it ispossible to realize autonomous features and 2) a smooth transition canbe made from existing E/E architectures, which have no explicit support for autonomy, to future E/E architectures that are explicitly designed for autonomy.The thesis begins its investigation by considering the specific problem of creating autonomous behavior under cooperative driving condi-tions. Cooperative driving conditions are those where continuous wireless communication exists between a vehicle and its surroundings, which consist of the local road infrastructure as well as the other vehicles in the vicinity. In this work, we define an original reference architecture for cooperative driving. The reference architecture demonstrates how a subsystem with specific autonomy features can be plugged into an existing E/E architecture, in order to realize autonomous driving capabilities. Two salient features of the reference architecture are that it isminimally invasive and that it does not dictate specific implementation technologies. The reference architecture has been instantiated on two separate occasions and is the main contribution of this thesis. Another contribution of this thesis is a novel approach to the design of general, autonomous, embedded systems architectures. The approach introduces an artificial consciousness within the architecture, that understands the overall purpose of the system and also how the different existing subsystems should work together in order to meet that purpose.This approach can enable progressive autonomy in existing embedded systems architectures, over successive design iterations.<br><p>QC 20130412</p>

Highly automated driving systems promise increased road traffic safety, as well as positive impacts on sustainable transportation by means of increased traffic efficiency and environmental friendliness. The design and development of such systems require scientific advances in a number of areas. One area is the vehicle's electrical/electronic (E/E) architecture. The E/E architecture can be presented using a number of views, of which an important one is the functional view. The functional view describes the decomposition of the system into its main logical components, along with the hierarchical structure, the component inter-connections, and requirements. When this view captures the principal ideas and patterns that constitute the foundation of a variety of specific architectures, it may be termed as a reference architecture. Two reference architectures for highly automated driving form the principal contribution of this thesis. The first reference architecture is for cooperative driving. In a cooperative driving situation, vehicles and road infrastructure in the vicinity of a vehicle continuously exchange wireless information and this information is then used to control the motion of the vehicle. The second reference architecture is for autonomous driving, wherein the vehicle is capable of driver-less operation even without direct communication with external entities. The description of both reference architectures includes their main components and the rationale for how these components should be distributed across the architecture and its layers. These architectures have been validated via multiple real-world instantiations, and the guidelines for instantiation also form part of the architecture description. A comparison with similar architectures is also provided, in order to highlight the similarities and differences. The comparisons show that in the context of automated driving, the explicit recognition of components for semantic understanding, world modeling, and vehicle platform abstraction are unique to the proposed architecture. These components are not unusual in architectures within the Artificial Intelligence/robotics domains; the proposed architecture shows how they can be applied within the automotive domain. A secondary contribution of this thesis is a description of a lightweight, four step approach for model based systems engineering of highly automated driving systems, along with supporting model classes. The model classes cover the concept of operations, logical architecture, application software components, and the implementation platforms. The thesis also provides an overview of current implementation technologies for cognitive driving intelligence and vehicle platform control, and recommends a specific setup for development and accelerated testing of highly automated driving systems, that includes model- and hardware-in-the-loop techniques in conjunction with a publish/subscribe bus. Beyond the more "traditional" engineering concepts, the thesis also investigates the domain of machine consciousness and computational self-awareness. The exploration indicates that current engineering methods are likely to hit a complexity ceiling, breaking through which may require advances in how safety-critical systems can self-organize, construct, and evaluate internal models to reflect their perception of the world. Finally, the thesis also presents a functional architecture for the brake system of an autonomous truck. This architecture proposes a reconfiguration of the existing brake systems of the truck in a way that provides dynamic, diversified redundancy, and an increase in the system reliability and availability, while meeting safety requirements.<br><p>QC 20151216</p>

Cette thèse explore le développement et la validation des systèmes de navigation autonome dans un environnement de réalité mixte (RM), avec pour objectif de combler l’écart entre la simulation virtuelle et les tests en conditions réelles. Les travaux mettent l’accent sur le potentiel des environnements en réalité mixte pour tester les systèmes autonomes de manière sûre, efficace et économique. La thèse est structurée en plusieurs parties, et commence par une revue des technologies de pointe dans la navigation autonome et les applications en réalité mixte. En utilisant des modèles à base de règles et des modèles d’apprentissage, des expérimentations visent à évaluer les performances des robots autonomes dans des environnements simulés, réels et de RM. Un des objectifs principaux est de réduire le « reality gap »—c’est-à-dire la différence entre les comportements observés en simulation et ceux observés dans des applications réelles—en intégrant des éléments réels avec des composants virtuels dans des environnements de RM. Cette approche permet des tests et une validation plus proche des contraintes réelles sans les risques associés aux essais physiques. Une partie importante du travail est consacrée à la mise en œuvre et au test d’une stratégie d’augmentation hors ligne visant à améliorer les capacités de perception des systèmes autonomes à l’aide des informations de profondeur. De plus, l’apprentissage par renforcement est appliqué pour évaluer son potentiel dans les environnements de RM. La thèse démontre que ces modèles peuvent apprendre efficacement à naviguer et à éviter les obstacles dans des simulations virtuelles et obtenir des résultats similaires lorsqu’ils sont transférés dans des environnements de RM, soulignant la flexibilité du cadre pour différents modèles de systèmes autonomes. À travers ces expériences, la thèse montre le potentiel des environnements de réalité mixte comme une plateforme polyvalente et robuste pour faciliter le développement des technologies de navigation autonome, offrant une approche plus sûre et plus évolutive pour la validation des modèles avant leur déploiement dans le monde réel<br>This thesis explores the development and validation of autonomous navigation systems within a mixed-reality (MR) framework, aiming to bridge the gap between virtual simulation and real-world testing. The research emphasizes the potential of MR environments for safely, efficiently, and cost-effectively testing autonomous systems. The thesis is structured around several chapters, beginning with a review of state-of-the-art technologies in autonomous navigation and mixed-reality applications. Through both rule-based and learning-based models, the research investigates the performance of autonomous robots within simulated, real, and MR environments. One of the core objectives is to reduce the "reality gap"—the discrepancy between behaviors observed in simulations versus real-world applications—by integrating real- world elements with virtual components in MR environments. This approach allows for more accurate testing and validation of algorithms without the risks associated with physical trials. A significant part of the work is dedicated to implementing and testing an offline augmentation strategy aimed at enhancing the perception capabilities of autonomous systems using depth information. Furthermore, reinforcement learning (RL) is applied to evaluate its potential within MR environments. The thesis demonstrates that RL models can effectively learn to navigate and avoid obstacles in virtual simulations and perform similarly well when transferred to MR environments, highlighting the framework’s flexibility for different autonomous system models. Through these experiments, the thesis establishes MR environments as a versatile and robust platform for advancing autonomous navigation technologies, offering a safer, more scalable approach to model validation before real-world deployment

Grâce à des mises à jour matérielles itératives et aux avancées dans les réseaux neuronaux profonds (DNN), les systèmes de conduite autonome (ADS) sont de plus en plus intégrés à la vie quotidienne. Cependant, avant que cette technologie ne se généralise, un problème de sécurité qui doit être résolu est celui des attaques adversariales physiques. Ces attaques peuvent manipuler des objets réels pour perturber la perception des ADS et provoquer des accidents de la route. De plus, la diversité des attaques physiques complique la tâche des défenseurs passifs.Cette étude aborde ces défis en analysant, évaluant et développant des stratégies pratiques pour améliorer la robustesse des ADS. Elle commence par une revue des récentes attaques adversariales physiques, identifiant les menaces spécifiques pour les ADS. Elle présente ensuite une nouvelle attaque black-box basée sur l'attention publique, qui démontre comment un attaquant peut exploiter la perception des ADS sans avoir une connaissance complète du système, soulignant ainsi la nécessité de renforcer les défenses.Ensuite, un cadre de détection léger est proposé pour la détection en temps réel des attaques laser. De plus, un mécanisme de défense nommé Laser shield est développé, utilisant des polariseurs pour bloquer les signaux laser nuisibles et renforcer la sécurité des ADS<br>With iterative hardware upgrades and advancements in deep neural networks (DNNs), autonomous driving systems (ADS) are increasingly integrated in life. However, before this technology becomes widespread, a security issue that needs to be addressed is physical adversarial attacks. Such attacks can manipulate real-world objects to disrupt the perception of ADSs and cause traffic accidents. In addition, the diversity of physical attacks makes it difficult for passive defenders.This study addresses these challenges by analyzing, evaluating, and developing practical strategies to improve the robustness of ADS.It begins with a review of recent physical adversarial attacks that identifies specific threats to ADSs.It then introduces a novel public attention-based black-box attack that demonstrates how an attacker can exploit ADS awareness without full knowledge of the system, highlighting the need for enhanced defenses.Next, a lightweight detection framework is proposed for real-time laser-based attack detection. Additionally, a defense mechanism called Laser Shield is developed, using polarizers to block harmful laser signals and enhance ADS security

Model Based Systems Engineering (MBSE) approach aims at implementing various processes of Systems Engineering (SE) through diagrams that provide different perspectives of the same underlying system. This approach provides a basis that helps develop a complex system in a systematic manner. Thus, this thesis aims at deriving a system model through this approach for the purpose of autonomous driving, specifically focusing on developing the subsystem responsible for generating a feasible trajectory for a miniature vehicle, called AutoCar, to enable it to move towards a goal. The report provides a background on MBSE and System Modeling Language (SysML) which is used for modelling the system. With this background, an MBSE framework for AutoCar is derived and the overall system design is explained. This report further explains the concepts involved in autonomous trajectory planning followed by an introduction to Robot Operating System (ROS) and its application for trajectory planning of the system. The report concludes with a detailed analysis on the benefits of using this approach for developing a system. It also identifies the shortcomings of applying MBSE to system development. The report closes with a mention on how the given project can be further carried forward to be able to realize it on a physical system.<br>Modellbaserade systemteknikens (MBSE) inriktning syftar till att implementera de olika processerna i systemteknik (SE) genom diagram som ger olika perspektiv på samma underliggande system. Detta tillvägagångssätt ger en grund som hjälper till att utveckla ett komplext system på ett systematiskt sätt. Sålunda syftar denna avhandling att härleda en systemmodell genom detta tillvägagångssätt för autonom körning, med särskild inriktning på att utveckla delsystemet som är ansvarigt för att generera en genomförbar ban för en miniatyrbil, som kallas AutoCar, för att göra det möjligt att nå målet. Rapporten ger en bakgrund till MBSE and Systemmodelleringsspråk (SysML) som används för modellering av systemet. Med denna bakgrund, MBSE ramverket för AutoCar är härledt och den övergripande systemdesignen förklaras. I denna rapport förklaras vidare begreppen autonom banplanering följd av en introduktion till Robot Operating System (ROS) och dess tillämpning för systemplanering av systemet. Rapporten avslutas med en detaljerad analys av fördelarna med att använda detta tillvägagångssätt för att utveckla ett system. Det identifierar också bristerna för att tillämpa MBSE på systemutveckling. Rapporten stänger med en omtale om hur det givna projektet kan vidarebefordras för att kunna realisera det på ett fysiskt system.

It is inevitable that as a person ages they will encounter different physical and cognitive impairments as well as dynamic social issues. We started this project under the assumption that autonomous driving would greatly benefit the fastest growing population in developed countries, the elderly. However, the larger question at hand was how are older drivers going to interact with future automated driving systems? It was through the qualitative research we conducted that we were able to uncover the answer to this question; older drivers are not willing to give up “control” to autonomous cars. As interaction designers, we need to define what type of interactions need to occur in these future automated driving systems, so older drivers still feel independent and in control when driving. Lawrence D. Burns, former Vice president of Research and Development at General Motors and author of Reinventing the Automobile Personal Urban Mobility for the 21st Century talks about two driving factors that will shape the future of the automobile. These factors are energy and connectivity (Burns et al., 2010). We would add a third one, which is control. If we address these three factors we might be able to bridge the gap between how we drive today and how we will drive in the future and thus create more cohesive future automated driving systems.