Francisco, André. "“Small town, big hell”." M/C Journal 28, no. 1 (2025). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3134.
Abstract:
Introduction The city is one of the most common iconographies associated with film noir, particularly at night. For several noir critics, the city is an inseparable and determining element in the definition, narrative structure, and aesthetic of film noir. However, while urban spaces dominate classic imagery, noir has also engaged significantly with rural and small-town settings. These spaces challenge the presumed centrality of the city, revealing noir’s capacity to explore moral decay, isolation, and violence beyond the urban landscape. This article examines the role of rural and small-town spaces in noir, centring the television series Mare of Easttown (2021) as an example of “small-town noir”. Set in a working-class town in Pennsylvania, the series illustrates how noir narratives adapt to non-urban landscapes, using these environments to explore themes of entrapment, generational trauma, and social disintegration. Unlike the anonymous and sprawling cityscapes of traditional noir, Mare of Easttown situates its story in a close-knit yet fractured community, where the relationships change the meaning of the crime and the dynamic of the investigation. Through the analysis of Mare of Easttown, this article focusses on how television has become a significant platform for the evolution of noir, offering space to explore narrative complexities and spatial diversity. The setting of Mare of Easttown asserts that noir’s essential characteristics—moral ambiguity, disillusionment, and entrapment—are not bound to the city but can also resonate in small-town settings. Noir beyond the City It is hard to separate film noir from the urban space; in fact, most studies place the city as a central and determining element in its aesthetics and in the construction of the narrative itself. James Naremore states that noir evokes a series of generic and stylistic characteristics, one of which is the urban setting, particularly diners, decadent offices, or stylish nightclubs (1). Regarding noir's relationship with the city, Nicholas Christopher states that the city is an essential element of noir. He adds that the “two are inseparable” since the vast American metropolis, with its dynamic mix of greatness and decadence, serves as the perfect backdrop for noir (37). The inseparability between urban space and noir is also mentioned by Andrew Dickos. The author states that one of the determining structural elements of noir is the existence of an urban setting or at least the existence of an urban influence (6). For Imogen Sara Smith the importance of the city in noir is intrinsically linked to one of the main antagonisms that arises in this type of film: the conflict between the values of individual freedom and community security. The author adds that “film noir is about people who break the rules, pursuing their own interests outside the boundaries of decent society, and about how they are destroyed by society – or by themselves” (2). Thus, faced with the impossibility of standing up to the magnitude of society, the protagonists of noir are driven to despair, feeling an intense need to escape. For this reason, one of the central motifs is precisely the idea that there is no escape. Therefore, noir is about characters struggling to survive and, ultimately, to escape what Lewis Mumford calls the megalopolis. The city functions as a perfect metaphor for imprisonment and is decisive in the construction of the very narrative structure of noir. As Eddie Muller points out: as in every noir, these folks will carom through a story line with a structure reflecting the city itself. Unexpected intersections. Twisted corridors. Secrets hidden in locked rooms. Lives dangling from dangerous heights. Abrupt dead ends. The blueprints were drawn up by a demented urban planner. (21) A possible reason for this emphasis on the importance of the city may be related to the attempts to conclusively categorise noir. One of the arguments pointed out by Smith is related to the need for many authors to try to define film noir as a genre. The use of the city as an element that somehow supports their theories is justified by the fact that one of the ways of defining a genre is through the setting or subject manner. This is the case for the Western with its strong connection to the American West, or the war films, which tend to take place on the battlefield, and so on, whereas film noir is too diverse to be classified in such a precise way. Noir is far too complex to be classified so distinctly since it embraces other genres such as the gangster, the heist, the melodrama, and even the Western. It is therefore easier to understand it by assuming film noir as “a mood, a stance, an attitude. It is defined not by any single element but by a combination of content, style and theme” (Smith 4). Another aspect that may be brought to the Smith argument is the fact that, although the representation of urban space is more consistently associated with noir than other elements, the reality is that there are several films whose action takes place in rural spaces or small towns. For example, in On Dangerous Ground (1951), the protagonist is transferred from New York City to a rural community upstate in the hope that a less chaotic environment will have a healing effect. In Out of the Past (1947), Jeff Bailey takes refuge in the small town of Bridgeport in an attempt to escape his criminal past. However, the examples are not restricted to the classic noir period. In contemporary times, these locations are also central to some noir-influenced narratives, namely Fargo (1996), Winter's Bone (2010), Cold in July (2014), or Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017), just to name a few. Nevertheless, the differences between noirs set in urban areas and those set in rural areas or small towns are not restricted to a simple change of location. Although most small-town noirs deal with the same themes, using similar character types, their specificity lies in the fact that they offer a series of social, spatial, and visual readings of the American landscape. In this respect, Smith characterises the small towns of film noir as places dominated by oppressive forces, where the police serve their own interests or those who have more power, rather than strictly following the law (83). As a result, certain illegal activities take place in plain sight, without any consequences. In turn, anyone who destabilises the harmony of the small town quickly becomes a target, and sooner or later they suffer the repercussions of their intrusion. Consequently, these places are apparently peaceful and perfect, but behind this false cover, they hide dangerous secrets, violence, or fanaticism. In short, they are spaces where everyone knows each other and where it is almost impossible to get away from assumptions and from the past (Smith 83). On the complexity of the small towns, Imogen Sara Smith notes: small towns are sentimentally cherished in American culture, but they also stand for complacency; their inhabitants are typed as narrow-minded, conservative, ignorant, self-righteous, and distrustful of outsiders. The nosy, judgmental, trouble-making gossip who spies on her neighbors and broadcasts their perceived failings is a ubiquitous type in classic Hollywood films. (83) The concept of the small town that the author draws is explored by noir through the representation of communities that tend to restrict freedom and incite intolerance. Accordingly, the more closed the community seems to be, the more vulnerable it becomes to being corrupted. The decline in morality is shared by the whole community, which remains in silence, while violence and money replace justice and law in the small-town structure. While in thematic and narrative terms small-town noir tends to explore the idea of a small, innocent, and fragile community, these are places highly marked by corruption and violence. Regarding the formal aspects of small-town noir, Jonathan F. Bell (230) notes that there are significant differences from urban noir. In urban noir, the opening shots are usually images of a huge, labyrinthine city, as in Side Street (1950) or To Live and Die in L.A. (1985), but in small-town noir, the wide-open spaces are the visual counterpoint: for example, the first moments of Affliction (1997) or No Country for Old Men (2017). The landscape conveys an apparent sense of freedom and control, as it allows a complete understanding of the space through the gaze. Nonetheless, these formal devices are used within this landscape to create claustrophobic environments similar to those found in the city, such as dark, decaying bars or typical small-town police stations. Upon entering these spaces, the shadows and dead ends typical of urban noir take on a new aspect, proving that the dark forces of the genre are also widespread in rural areas (Bell 230). The author uses as an example the films The Postman Always Rings Twice (1946), in particular the scene in which Cora Smith (Lana Turner) is forced to climb the cliff through a narrow channel in a rock, creating a claustrophobic and acrophobic environment, and Gun Crazy (1950), specifically the final scene in which almost all visual resources are eliminated, focussing only on the two main characters who, exhausted, take refuge in the midst of a dense swamp (Bell 232). More contemporary films Blood Simple (1984) and Winter's Bone (2010) also use these visual resources. In the first, in the scene in which Marty (Dan Hedaya) tries to kidnap Abby (Frances McDormand), the light cut by the shutters, typical of noir, is present throughout the scene, creating a threatening and enclosing atmosphere. In the second, when Merab (Dale Dickey) takes Ree (Jennifer Lawrence) to the middle of the lake so that she can see her father's body, the dim lighting and blue tones of the scene highlight the protagonist's state of restlessness and uncertainty. Other visual resources used are the images of long roads that cross the vast natural territory, with no sign of buildings or human presence. Ironically, this imagery can also represent a certain claustrophobia. The almost endless road towards the horizon carries a symbolic weight, representing in these films the only possible path or predetermined destination, from which there is no escape (Bell 232). Like the future of the protagonists, when you look at these roads, you can see nothing but the continuous landscape. In the opening scene of the film Key Largo (1948), the tar road is the only route to the Florida Keys and, consequently, the only means by which the divergent characters will meet (Bell 233). In Fargo (1996), the opening scene sets the mood and pace of the film when the black screen turns white, slowly revealing a car driving along a road completely covered in snow and seemingly with no end in sight. Through these examples, we can conclude that the themes and visual conventions that were established in urban noir have been reproduced in rural and small-town spaces. Big cities were ideal for crime since they allowed a certain level of anonymity. In small towns, the more familiar and intimate environment increases the likelihood of the criminal being known by all the residents, making these actions even more disconcerting (Short 27). Hence, small-town noir allows for readings of the decaying American landscape, emphasising one of the main messages of noir: there is nowhere safe to go anymore. The approach of film noir to the spaces beyond the big city is largely related to more contemporary forms of noir, particularly through television series. These narratives have become a fruitful space for the development of noir-inspired stories that explore rural areas or small towns and their particularities far from large urban centres. Some examples include the series True Detective (2014-), Fargo (2014-), Ozark (2017-2022), and Sharp Objects (2018), among others. What they have in common is that they represent communities which, the more compact they are, the more deeply corruptible they become. As Smith states, in these places, “racketeering doesn’t only affect the hidden realm of government; it’s a shared, unspoken secret among all citizens”. Consequently, “truth itself is warped as people agree to accept the validity of lies” (92). Ultimately, justice and the law are dictated by money and violence in the structure of those societies. Taking this reading of the noir space in suburban areas of the USA as a starting point, this analysis explores how Mare of Easttown, from a contemporary perspective, draws inspiration from noir representations of the small town. Additionally, we will examine how space plays a decisive role in shaping the narrative and defining the characters, while embracing traditional noir themes. Mare of Easttown as Small-Town Noir The HBO series Mare of Easttown (2021) is a quintessential example of how contemporary noir narratives can explore the complexities of small-town life in suburban America. Through its noir-influenced storytelling, dark visual aesthetics, and morally ambiguous characters, Mare of Easttown delves into the socio-economic struggles, generational trauma, and intertwined personal histories that characterise the town of Easttown, Pennsylvania. In doing so, the series not only adheres to classic noir conventions but also redefines the genre by emphasising community and intimacy in ways that amplify the small-town setting. The series is built on the investigation of a teenage mother’s death, which turns into three different investigations into crimes against women. Two of them are related to the kidnapping and rape carried out by an outsider in the context of the small town. The third one, that of the young teenage mother, ends up being classified as domestic violence. The investigations are led by detective Mare Sheehan (Kate Winslet), a woman trying to find balance between family life and her work, but more than that, as a mother figure, Mare carries the weight of loss and guilt. This portrait of Mare as both protector and outcast emphasises the noir's interest in flawed heroes who operate in morally grey areas, divided between duty and personal demons. As a crime drama, the series explores the limits of the police's ability to break cycles of violence against women. In addition, it also examines how the community and family structures of those who live in the small town of Easttown can hide patterns of violence. In this regard, the small town presents itself as a familiar social environment, while at the same time it replicates some elements of the “big city”. For this reason, as Michael Dango points out: Mare of Easttown also figures a social environment that is both family and city at once, making it impossible to disentangle stranger rape and forms of acquaintance, date, or intimate partner rape – and therefore impossible to locate the problem of rape as one of crimes to be solved by the police; or one of ordinary heterosexuality, requiring more radical cultural transformation. (3) These patterns of violence and the intertwining of the intimate and the foreign are set against the backdrop of a community debilitated by deindustrialisation and loss of hope. Easttown is beset by issues like unemployment, addiction, and declining economic opportunities. These struggles contribute to the pervasive sense of hopelessness among the town’s residents, a mood reminiscent of classic noir’s fatalistic worldview. The series suggests that these economic pressures exacerbate human flaws, leading to violence and betrayal that often result from characters' efforts to escape or cope with their realities. Moreover, in Easttown, resignation replaces political anger, and it is individual failure rather than corporate greed that Mare's investigation reveals. The failures are mainly associated, but not exclusively, with the father figure. As Sue Thornham states, the several imperfect parental figures who appear in the series are interconnected by their inability to fulfill their duties as fathers or community leaders. Despite their anger, they are not necessarily tied to corruption or damaging expressions of masculinity (Thornham 4). In Mare of Easttown individual failure is, therefore, the failure of the community. This permanent sense of failure relates to the noir tradition of the pursuit of a derailed American Dream, but also to the idea of home and personal and social relationships being jeopardised in the face of weakness and desire. Similarly, the so-called societal institutions (family, marriage, law) and the idea that hard work is enough to overcome economic difficulties end up failing, leading to the consequent destabilisation of the community. In this regard, the series aligns with the noir critique of systemic inequalities, showing how a small town, although idealised as community-centred and healthy, can also be a place where hope is suppressed, and dreams turn to bitterness. The instability of the community is also related to the spatial restriction of the small town. If everyone knows each other and everyone has some kind of access to the privacy of the family, violence within the family not only becomes more “accessible”, but also more shocking. As one of the detectives in the series says during an interrogation: “Is there anybody you’re not related to?” The small town in Mare of Easttown allows for a uniquely noir exploration of interconnected lives and inescapable pasts. The relationships are multi-generational, which means that each action has a chain effect on the whole community. Secrets, past grudges, and untold stories influence present actions, with crimes and personal vendettas emerging as expressions of long-held resentments. This thematic focus is particularly effective in a small-town setting, where proximity and shared history intensify the characters’ entanglements. In noir, the protagonist often tries to escape a dark past or a corrupt urban landscape, but Mare's journey is the opposite: she is irrevocably linked to Easttown, a place that symbolises both her losses and failures and her loyalty and resistance. This portrait highlights the noir concept of “entrapment” while emphasising the small town as a space where the faults of the past endure, and the possibility of renewal or escape are limited. Conclusion Mare of Easttown can be understood as an insightful look at some of the main problems that haunt suburban and rural areas in the United States. It highlights issues such as the opioid crisis, insufficient health care, precariousness, and low-paying jobs, but also the desire of younger people to get out of their small town as quickly as possible. Crime in Easttown, in general, seems to be more related to the desperation of people obliged to subsist on less, than to pure malice. In addition, Mare of Easttown differentiates from other series by focussing on mundanity amid tragedy and by representing grief, sorrow, and forgiveness as a collective rather than an individual process. Moreover, all these processes are presented as part of everyday life and not just as an exception for dramatic effect. Crime, violence, pain, mourning, and forgiveness are consequences that do not affect just one character, but an entire community that needs to come together to heal. Through series like Mare of Easttown, despite the “hyperreal status and diffusion in popular culture”, as Lindsay Steenberg puts it, television offers the possibility “for the reconstitution of noir as a useful theoretical concept” (63), especially through the way it explores rural and suburban areas. Continuing the long tradition of noir, Mare of Easttown echoes Andrew Spicer's view that noir explores the “dark underside of the American dream. Because that dream forms the core mythology of global capitalism” (xlix). Noir, especially through series like Mare of Easttown, continues to be an important cultural phenomenon that is constantly evolving, a “crucial vehicle through which that mythology can be critiqued and challenged” (Spicer, xlix). References Affliction. Dir. Paul Schrader. Lions Gate Films, 1997. Bell, Jonathan F. “Shadows in the Hinterland: Rural Noir”. In Architecture and Film. Ed. Mark Lamster. Princeton Architectural Press, 2000. 222-234. Blood Simple. Dirs. Joel Coen and Ethan Coen. Circle Films, 1984. Christopher, Nicholas. Somewhere in the Night: Film Noir & the American City. The Free Press, 1997. Cold in July. Dir. Jim Mickle. IFC Films, 2014. Dango, Michael. “Post-Procedural Form and Rape Ambiance: Policing Sexual Violence in Mare of Easttown.” Television & New Media 25.5 (2024): 463-479. Dickos, Andrew. Street with No Name: A History of the Classic American Film. UP of Kentucky, 2002. Fargo [movie]. Dirs. Joel Coen and Ethan Coen. PolyGram Filmed Entertainment, 1996. Fargo [TV series]. Created by Noah Hawley. FX, 2014-. Gun Crazy. Dir. Joseph H. Lewis. United Artists, 1950. Key Largo. Dir. John Huston. Warner Bros, 1948. Mare of Easttown. Created by Brad Ingelsby. HBO, 2021. Muller, Eddie. Dark City: The Lost World of Film Noir. Running Press, 2021. Mumford, Lewis. The City in History: Its Origins, Its Transformations and Its Prospects. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1961. Naremore, James. More than Night: Film Noir in Its Contexts. U of California P, 2008. No Country for Old Men. Dirs. Joel Coen and Ethan Coen. Miramax Films, 2017. On Dangerous Ground. Dir. Nicholas Ray. RKO Radio Pictures, 1951. Out of the Past. Dir. Jacques Tourneur. RKO Radio Pictures, 1947. Ozark. Created by Bill Dubuque and Mark Williams. Netflix, 2017-2022. Side Street. Dir. Anthony Mann. MGM, 1950. Sharp Objects. Created by Marti Noxon. HBO, 2018. Short, Sue. Darkness Calls: A Critical Investigation of Neo-Noir. Palgrave Macmillan, 2019. Smith, Imogen Sara. In Lonely Places: Film Noir beyond the City. McFarland & Company, 2011. Spicer, Andrew. Historical Dictionary of Film Noir. Scarecrow Press, 2010. Steenberg, Lindsay. “The Fall and Television Noir.” Television & New Media 18.1 (2017): 58-75. The Postman Always Rings Twice. Dir. Tay Garnett. MGM, 1946. Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri. Dir. Martin McDonagh. Fox Searchlight Pictures, 2017. Thornham, Sue. “Breathing Spaces? The Politics of Embodiment, Affect, and Genre in Mare of Easttown and Happy Valley.” Feminist Media Studies 23.5 (2023): 2254-2268. To Live and Die in L.A. Dir. William Friedkin. MGM, 1985. True Detective. Created by Nic Pizzolatto. HBO, 2014-. Winter’s Bone. Dir. Debra Granik. Roadside Attractions, 2010.