Academic literature on the topic 'Merluccius paradoxus – South Africa'

Abstract Edwards, C. T. T., Rademeyer, R. A., Butterworth, D. S., and Plagányi, É. E. 2009. Investigating the consequences of Marine Protected Areas for the South African deep-water hake (Merluccius paradoxus) resource. – ICES Journal of Marine Science, 66: 72–81. Protected areas are often touted as important management tools to mitigate the uncertainty inherent in marine ecosystems, and thereby improve the long-term prospects for sustainable resource use. However, although they certainly play an important role in conservation, their usefulness in improving fishery yields is contentious. We present a simulation model that explores spatial closure options, and apply it to the demersal hake trawl fishery off South Africa. The model is based on the age-structured approach used for current assessments, representing the dynamics of the deep-water hake Merluccius paradoxus within a zonally disaggregated spatial system. Fitting the model to two zones, which demarcate a potential closed area from the remaining fished area, we investigate the consequences that such a protected area could have for the fishery. Our model suggests that area closures would have a negligible benefit for the fishery, regardless of the level of hake movement between areas. This is likely the result of the model's simplicity, and we suggest additional factors that should be considered to quantify the impact of Marine Protected Areas on the fishery more reliably.

A new species of myxosporean parasite is described from the gall bladders of the hakes Merluccius capensis Castelnau and M. paradoxus Franca (Pisces: Teleostei) caught off the west and south coasts of South Africa. The new species, Pseudalataspora vanderlingeni, is described morphologically and molecularly and compared with the 15 other species of Pseudalataspora previously described from marine fish. Although a molecular description is available on GenBank for only one of these 15 species, the morphological description supports the status of P. vanderlingeni as a new species. Earlier reports, without detailed descriptions, of Leptotheca sp. and Ceratomyxa sp. from the same hosts caught off Namibia were very likely to have been of P. vanderlingeni. These earlier studies reported high prevalences of infection, similar to those of >60% described in the present study. The effects of fixation and freezing on the dimensions of spores of Pseudalataspora spp. are described, and the status of the genus Pseudalataspora within the family Ceratomyxidae is discussed.

Stomachs of 385 specimens of Seriola dumerili (Risso, 1810) have been analysed. Their coefficient of repletion is 50·8% in juveniles and 90·3% in adults. Juveniles feed almost exclusively on Teleostei with Engraulis encrasicholus and Sardina pilchardus as the main food; Cephalopoda (Loligo vulgaris and Sepiola sp.) and Crustacea (Squilla mantis) are also eaten. Adults feed on a great diversity of Teleostei headed by S. pilchardus and Merluccius merluccius.According to Smith-Vaniz (1986)Seriola dumerili is both epibenthic and pelagic, occurring at 18–72 m in small to moderate schools. Juveniles are associated with flotsam in oceanic or offshore neritic waters. Adults often live near reefs or at deep off-shore holes or drop-offs. It is found from the Mediterranean and the Bay of Biscay to South Africa, from Nova Scotia to Brazil, and also in the Arabian Gulf, Australia, Japan and the Hawaiian Islands.

The motivation for this study was to examine the exploitation patterns of the M. capensis and M. paradoxus hake fisheries on the Southeast Coast, and determine the size and species of hake caught in each of the hand-line, long-line, and trawl methods. The handline hake fishery has increased substantially over the last several years and concerns are beginning to emerge about the impact this will have on the inshore resource collected on the South Coast between August 1998 and July 1999 was used to describe the hand-line method and estimate annual landings. Data on the size and species in longline catches of hake caught during 1997 were already available for this study. Size distributions in trawl catches were determined from commercial category landing data reported by catch weight and depth. The species composition in these catches determined by comparison using RV Afrikana survey data collected in the same depth regions. Location plays a significant role in determining the sizes and species of hake caught by each gear. Hand-lines catch smaller sizes on average than do long-lines, inshore trawls target mainly M. capensis while offshore trawls catch both hake species. A substantial amount of the hand-line hake caught on the South Coast is not reported. Examination of the exploitation patterns reveal that intense trawling pressure is directed at the smaller sized M. paradoxus inhabiting the depth region between 160-400-meters. Inshore trawls discard a large amount of small sized M. capensis within the 100-meter isobath. A preliminary stock assessment on the status of each hake species found that M. paradoxus appears to be over-exploited while M. capensis was in better shape. However, length-based pseudo-cohort analysis, used in this assessment, is critically reliant on having length frequency data from a steady state population in equilibrium. This limits the application of this model for management purposes and this finding is purely theoretical at this stage. Results suggest that each hake species is under a different pattern and level of exploitation and the multi-species nature of hake stocks on the South Coast should be considered in developing optimum management policies. Future work should focus on developing appropriate age/length keys so that an age-based VPA, which is more powerful than the length-based approach, can be applied towards stock assessments on the South Coast. Alternatively, length-data covering a longer period should be compiled and the equilibrium assumption further investigated so that the results from length-based models can be used with more confidence.

Thesis (D. Tech. Environmental health) -- Central University of technology, Free State, 2011
Apart from being the primary food source of many cultures around the world, fish contains notable amounts of essential fatty acids that are required by the human body, thus making fish a vital part of the human diet. In South Africa Cape hake is a well-known and highly consumed local fish species, which is transported from coastal areas countrywide where the fresh fish are displayed on ice in various retail stores. Fish is known to be highly susceptible to spoilage and, as a result, the maintenance of the cold-chain in related products is of particular importance. Additionally, recent trends showing a decline in natural fish resources have instigated growing concerns about the sustainability and optimal utilisation of fish as a food source. Against this backdrop, this study aimed at determining the influence of storage parameters on selected triglycerides and their possible metabolic pathways. Also applying prediction modelling of fatty acids and volatiles as instruments to assess exposure of Cape hake fillets to excessive microbial contamination and, in effect, be indicative of the environmental parameters (for example temperature) that may influence such contamination. Randomly selected juvenile hakes were filleted and stored under various simulated retail storage conditions, under either controlled or uncontrolled environmental conditions. For each hake filleted, one fillet was inoculated with an increased load of autochthonous microbiota, and the corresponding fillet was kept at similar temperature conditions. All fillets were monitored over a ten day period, during which fatty acid and volatile samples were collected and analysed. From the resulting triglycerides a selection of fatty acids were profiled and their possible metabolic pathways investigated. Fish maturity, the distribution of the fatty acids and the implication thereof in the nutritional value were also assessed. Conventional chemometric methods utilising mathematical expressions were subsequently utilised in order to predict contamination and whether the cold chain was sustained, while an artificial neural network (ANNs) were designed to predict excessive microbial contamination in the fillets. The results showed that the nutritional value of fish differs notably with its maturity and size. Mathematical equations were furthermore found to be effective assessment instruments to indicate the percentage differences in storage temperature, as well as consequent microbial influences. Thus, this approach may introduce mathematical prediction modelling as a promising mechanism to assess Cape hake spoilage. An artificial neural network (ANN) was successfully designed, that succeeded in distinguishing between Cape hake fillets displayed and stored on ice that have been exposed to excessive contamination and those that have not been exposed. In the latter case, the selected variable was a fatty acid, hexadecanoic acid, used as biochemical indicator. This modulating approach may provide a platform for future shelf-life studies on related muscle tissue. Ultimately, the study endeavoured to add to the body of knowledge regarding the biochemical and microbiological changes related to Cape hake storage, the prediction thereof via contemporary methods and contributing to the safety and effective utilization of this unique and declining South African nutritional resource.

Thesis (MScAgric)--University of Stellenbosch, 2004.
ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Cape hake (Merluccius capensis and M. paradoxus) is commercially the most important trawl-caught fish off the South African, coastline and due to current intensive fish processing procedures Cape hake contributes the most to the total fishwaste production. Besides its commercial importance fish is also regarded as one of the single most important consumable natural resources, either in the raw or frozen form. Most of South Africa's commercially trawled demersal fish has already been partially cleaned (i.e. headed and gutted) before landing with non-marketable bycatch and hake-waste normally disposed of as discards, resulting in a waste of a potential protein source. This study was thus aimed at fulfilling several objectives namely: observing the current large-scale commercial Cape hake harvesting procedure; constructing prediction models for several morphological parameters (whole hake mass, headed & gutted hake mass, hake head mass, hake head length, hake head breadth and hake head height) of Cape hake (Merluccius ssp.), using whole hake length as the independent variable; and determining the chemical composition (moisture, protein, fat, ash, macro and trace elements) of several hake head sections (clean head, neck flesh, tongue, tongue cartilage, jaw, gills, heart, intestines, gut, kidney, kidney & kidney bone and gut & gall); determining the effect that storage has on the fatty acid profile of both the clean head and neck flesh sections. The results obtained would supply necessary data required for techno-economic investigations in the use of hake heads. For each of the six prediction models constructed, there was an increase in the variance of the data points of categories 3 (64-80 cm) and 4 (>80 cm) as opposed to categories 1 (30-46 cm) and 2 (47-63 cm). This could be attributed to a smaller sample set for both categories 3 and 4 or due to an expected increase in the variance when investigating larger biological samples. There was also a clustering of data in the three areas for each prediction model namely, within category 1 and across categories 2 and 3 and 3 and 4. This emphasised the latitudinal stratification of the Cape hake population by age, hence their stratification by size. The prediction models constructed for both boat trips 2 and 3 differed significantly (p<0.01) from that of boat trip 1, with the exception of the hake head length (cm) prediction model. The constructed prediction models, for each of the three respective boat trips, showed good predictive abilities as was indicated by the low Mean Square Error (MSE) values for the test sets, and high Pearson's correlation coefficient (r) values. These prediction models can be used in the fishing industry with confidence for Cape hake within the time frame each respective boat trip was carried out. The neck flesh could be regarded as the most important concerning chemical composition whereas the jaw could be seen as the most important when one considers mineral content. This therefore means that the jaw section, once appropriately processed is a potential Ca, Na and Fe source for supplementing diets of people suffering from a Ca, Na or Fe deficient diet. With regard to chemical status the neck flesh section is seen as a good potential source of both protein and fat, which could be attributed to the fact that hake muscle constitutes a major portion of this section. This section could thus be used to supplement the protein and fat of an existing food product, which is protein and fat deficient for people suffering from a protein and fat deficient diet. Similarly, a market could be created for the production of an economical food product with the neck flesh section being the main ingredient. Once this have been accomplished, fishing vessels may be persuaded to retain their Cape hake fish-waste for further processing due to the value of the prepared food products and thereby maintain profitability while abiding to governmental law. In conclusion non-government scientists should have more input in the decision-making process concerning matters affecting South Africa's marine biodiversity in order for future key policy and legislation drafts to be effective. Improvement of current fish preservation techniques and the known chemical composition of currently discarded material will result in informed decisions of future matters concerning its disposal.
AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Kaapse stokvis (Merluccius capensis en M. paradoxus) is kommersieel Suid-Afrika se belangrikste vis spesie. Aangesien die Suid-Afrikaanse visprosesseringsbedryf baie intensief is, dra die Kaapse stokvis verwerkingsindustrie die grootste gedeelte by tot die totale visafval produksie. Die meeste van Suid-Afrika se visvangste word gedeeltelik skoongemaak voor landing terwyl nie-kommersiële byvangste en visafval gewoonlik oorboord gegooi word tydens die vangproses. Dit lei tot die vermorsing van 'n potensïele proteïen bron. Hierdie studie was dus gemik om: die huidige grootskaalse kommersiële Kaapse stokvis visvangsproses waar te neem; voorspellingsmodelle vir verskeie morfologiese parameters (heel vis massa, vis massa sonder kop en binnedele, stokvis kop massa, stokvis kop lengte, stokvis kop breedte en stokvis kop hoogte) vir Kaapse stokvis (Merluccius ssp.) te ontwikkel deur die hele lengte van die vis te gebruik as die onafhanklike veranderlike; die chemiese samestelling (vog, proteïen, vet, as, makro en spoor elemente) van verskillende dele van die viskop (skoonkop, nekweefsel, tong, tong kraakbeen, kaak, kiewe, hart, ingewand, derm, nier, nier & nierbeen en derm & gal); sowel as die effek van opberging op die vetsuurprofiel van beide die skoonkop en nekweefsel dele van die Kaapse stokvis kop. Hierdie resultate sal dan gebruik word vir die tegnies-ekonomies ondersoek in die gebruik van Kaapse stokvis koppe. Vir elk van die ses voorspellingsmodelle ontwikkel, was daar 'n vermeerdering in die variansie van die datapunte vir kategorieë 3 (64-80 cm) en 4 (>80 cm) teenoor kategorieë 1 (30-46 cm) en 2 (47-63 cm). Dit kan moontlik wees as gevolg van die kleiner monster trekking vir beide kategorieë 3 en 4 of as gevolg van verwagte toename in variansie wanneer groter biologiese monsters ondersoek word. Daar was ook 'n groepering van data in drie plekke vir elke voorspellingsmodel naamlik; binne in kategorieë 1 en oor kategorieë 2 en 3 en 3 en 4. Dit beklemtoon die geografiese breedte van die Kaapse stokvis populasie op grond van ouderdom, en dus die geografiese breedte op grond van grootte. Die voorspellingsmodelle ontwikkel vir beide die tweede en derde bootvangs het betekenisvol verskil (p<0.01) van die eerste bootvangs, behalwe die vir die stokvis kop lengte (cm) voorspellingsmodel. Die voorspellingsmodelle vir elk van die bootvangste het goeie voorspellingsvermoë getoon wat bewys is deur die lae Gemiddelde Kwadraat Fout waardes vir toetsgroepe en hoë Pearson's korrelasie koeffisiënt (r) waardes. Hierdie voorspellingsmodelle wat ontwikkel is, kan dus met vertroue in die Kaapse stokvis visvangsbedryf gebruik word mits dit ooreenstem met die periode waarin elke bootvangs uitgevoer was. Die nekweefsel gedeelte is die mees belangrikste met betrekking tot chemiese samestelling en die kaak die belangrikste in terme van minerale samestelling van die verskeie viskop dele. Die kaak is dus, as dit voldoende geprosesseer word, 'n goeie potensïele bron van Ca, Na en Fe en kan dus gebruik word om die dieet van mense wat 'n gebrek het aan hierdie minerale aan te vul. Met betrekking tot die chemiese samestelling van die nekweefsel gedeelte kan dit beskou word as 'n goeie potensiële bron van beide proteïen en vet, wat toegeskryf kan word aan die feit dat spierweefsel 'n groot deel uitmaak van hierdie viskop gedeelte. Hierdie viskop gedeelte sal dus uitstekend wees om die proteïen- en vetinhoud van 'n voedselproduk wat van nature 'n lae proteïen- en vetinhoud het te verhoog en hierdie produk sou dan geteiken word op daardie gedeelte van die gemeenskap wat 'n proteïen en vet tekort in hul dieet het. As dit eers alles in plek is, dan sal die visvangs bedryf hul Kaapse stokvis afval behou vir verdere prosessering deurdat dit gebruik word om die voedingsinhoud van bestaande voedsel soorte sal verbeter en terselfdertyd sal hulle aan wetgewing voldoen. Gevolglik sal nie-regerings navorsers meer betrokke moet wees by die besluitnemingsproses met betrekking tot sake wat die Suid-Afrikaanse mariene lewe affekteer en wat toekomstige wetgewing meer effektief sal maak. Die verbetering van huidige vis preserveringstegnieke gepaardgaande met die kennis van die chemiese samestelling van die Kaapse stokvis koppe sal lei na beter toekomstige besluite oor die afset daarvan.

Includes bibliographical references.
Standard weight (Ws) equations were developed and relative weight (Wr) indices calculated for both shallow-water (Merluccius capensis) and deep-water (M . paradoxus) Cape hake. The aim was to provide fixed baselines and Wr indices to aid understanding of temporal and spatial variability in fish condition . Baselines were calculated using the empirical percentiles (EmP) method applied to length (L) – weight (W) data collected by research surveys on the South African west and south coasts, from 1983 to 2013 . Four quadratic Ws equations for each species were generated, based on the following weight statistics for each size class j : first quartile, median, third quartile and mean. Median Ws equations were chosen for the baseline for shallow-water hake (log₁₀ Ws=-2.491 + 3.33 8 *(log₁₀ L)-0.065 *(log₁₀ Lj)²) and deep-water hake (log₁₀ Ws =- 2.161 + 2.930*(log₁₀ L) + 0.0456 *(log 10Lj)²). Shallow-water hake was found to be the heavier of the two species at the same length. Wr indices display good condition values (>100%) for both species throughout all analyses . Fish condition for both species was best between 1988-2009, ranging from 50-1 65% for individual fish and 100 – 109% for annual averages. Monthly mean Wr indices peaked in June and October for shallow-water hake and July and October for deep-water hake. Mean Wr values were different for shallow-water hake on the south (105%) and west (103%) coasts. Deep-water hake showed no spatial variability in mean Wr values. There were no differences between mean Wr values of males and females between, and within, species. Future hake data may be compared to these Ws equation baselines and Wr indices to show changes in body condition for this commercially important stock.

The South African hake resource faces divergent fishing pressures and management issues. Although the resource consists of two species, management was simplified because the resource was only subject to trawl effort and because of the similarity in population parameters, single species assessment models could be adopted. The impact of trawling on the stock is considered to be well understood and the resource has shown recovery since exclusion of foreign vessels. The 1990s were punctuated by major political change and the need for transformation has resulted in an expansion of the number of fishing rights holders. Longlining has been reintroduced and there is no clear understanding of how the combined fishing pressures will affect the population structure of either Merluccius capensis or M. paradoxus. Information is vital to successful management. Fisheries are complex and intricate, and at times appear impossible to control or monitor. An integrated information system provides easily understood graphical explanations of complex issues. This thesis assessed the dynamics of the trawl and longline fisheries between 1994 and 1999 using a geographical information system (GIS). The accessability of a GIS incorporates the needs of scientists, managers and fishing communities. The simple GIS developed in this study revealed shifts in effort, facilitated the calculation of spatially precise catches and biomasses and highlighted the inadequacy of current sampling coverage. Trawlers were shown to fish the same areas consistently during the years investigated, with highest fishing intensity and average CPUE achieved at depths between 300 and 500m. Analysis of the longline sector revealed several similarities to the trawl sector, fishing intensity was highest between 301 and 500m, suggesting that both sectors face a "friction of distance" dilemma. The distribution and abundance of hake, in particular the exploitable proportion of the population, was determined by a combination of depth and substrate type. The selectivity patterns of trawlers and longliners were briefly investigated with the results illustrating that gear selectivity of the M. capensis stock was depth dependent. The deeper fishing occurred, the larger the length-at-selection. As a result, the M. capensis parental stock faces unprecedented fishing pressure. In the absence of reliable species-specific catch data, logistic and linear regression models were developed to split the hake catch into its respective species components. Large discrepancies between the predicted M. capensis catch for the two models were noted. Regression estimates constructed at a finer spatial scale may provide a better fit than the current depth logistic employed by Marine and Coastal Management. A first attempt at assessing the M. capensis resource on the West Coast using an age-structured production model was presented. It was found that a lengthy and accurate M. capensis catch series is required before it is possible to successfully model the dynamics of the stock. It is necessary to incorporate finer spatial detail in the collation of catch data and collection of sampling data. It would be unadvisable to assume that the stock is stable or recovering. The implications of a size/sex relationship must be investigated and properly appraised.

The unidentified pathogen, known as 'Frill on Gill’ (FOG), infects the shallow-water Cape hake Merluccius capensis off the south and west coast of South Africa. This pathogen, a parasitic castrator, occurs on the gill filaments of infected fish. This study investigates the effects of this pathogen on the body condition of M. capensis on the south coast of South Africa, through the use of two body condition measures, condition factor and hepatosomatic index (HSI). A total of 24275 M. capensis were sampled, of which 825 (3.4%) were infected with the FOG pathogen. The smallest M. capensis infected with FOG was 10 cm, and the largest was 84 cm. The smallest uninfected M. capensissampled was 6 cm and the largest was 106 cm. The presence of FOG had a significant impact on the condition factor and HSI of M. capensis (three-way analysis of variance (ANOVA): p-value = 0.002, and p-value = 5.13e-09 respectively), with the effect of the pathogen varying with length. For fish with a total length smaller than 26 cm, infected M. capensis were in poorer condition than uninfected fish at the same length, with lower condition factors and HSI values. However, for M. capensis with lengths between 30 and 34 cm, 42 and 46 cm, 54 and 62 cm, and 78 and 82 cm, the condition factors of FOG infected fish were higher than uninfected fish. The HSI values of M. capensis infected with FOG also steadily increase above those of uninfected fish, for lengths greater than 42 cm. The lower body condition measures of uninfected M. capensis could be linked to the large amounts of energy that these fish expend during reproduction and gonad maturation. In contrast, M. capensis infected with FOG do not partake in the energy intensive task of reproduction. Merluccius capensis infected with FOG don’t contribute to reproduction, but still compete with uninfected M. capensis for resources. The effect of FOG as a type of parasitic castrator on the regulation of M. capensis populations could become a concern for fishery managers, as they reduce reproductive output and impact fish body condition.

This study presents a detailed investigation into size, density and community structure of temperate marine reef fish in the medium-sized Goukamma Marine Protected Area (Goukamma MPA) and adjacent fishing grounds on the south coast of South Africa. The oceanographic conditions, the spatial distribution of the benthic community and the prevailing fishing effort are also described. Life history traits and per-recruit (PR) models for the principle target species, roman (Crysoblephus laticeps) are compared between the protected and exploited area. From the study results, various strategies are proposed for the use of MPAs in the conservation and management of linefish species along South Africa’s south coast. The distribution and topography of reefs in the protected and exploited sections of the study area were found to be comparable. Atmospheric pressure ranged from 992 to 1,032 mb, being significantly lower in summer. Wind speeds ranged from 0.7 to 71.3 km/h. Water temperatures ranged between 9.0 and 22.2 ºC and turbidity between 0.3 and 45.8 NTU. Water temperature and clarity were uniformly low in winter. In summer the water was generally warm, clear and stratified, with a thermocline at around 20 m, although intermittent upwelling events caused water temperature to decrease and clarity to deteriorate. Current speeds ranged between 0.11 and 2.59 km/h and were significantly higher in spring and autumn. Easterly currents prevailed in spring, summer and autumn and westerly and southerly currents in winter. Hake (Merluccius capensis), various resident reef fish and kob (Argyrosomus japonicus) were most frequently targeted by the local linefishery. A significant amount of illegal fishing was found to occur in the protected area. Fishing effort was found to be highest around the border of the MPA (2.7 boats/km²) and lowest in the core of the MPA (0.2 boats/km²). If law enforcement remains poor it may be necessary to adapt the management strategy to extend the reserve, thereby mitigating against illegal fishing and ensuring a core area of no exploitation. Various other alternatives were investigated and it was demonstrated that the amount of fish caught of legal size could be increased by about 23% and post-release mortality of undersized fish reduced by 50% through the introduction of a suit of restrictive measures. Randomly stratified underwater visual census (UVC) and controlled fishing were used to investigate the ichthyofauna and benthic community at protected and exploited sites in the study area. Resulting density and size data from 273 fishing sites and 177 point counts were analyzed using generalized linear models (GLMs). Fish communities were found to vary significantly, depending on the level of exploitation. Roman, the principle reef fish species targeted by the fishery had significantly higher densities within the protected parts of the study area (CPUE: 4.3 fish/anglerhour; UVC: 2.2 fish/point-count) as compared to the exploited part (CPUE: 3.4 fish/anglerhour; UVC: 1.8 fish/point-count), correlating strongly with the observed fishing effort. Also mean sizes were significantly higher in the protected area (299 mm from fishing survey and 233 mm from diving estimates) as compared to the exploited section (283 mm from fishing survey and 198 mm from diving estimates). Although other fish species also had significantly higher mean sizes at protected sites in most cases their densities were significantly lower. This suggests a top-down control of the fish community by the dominant predator (roman). The results of the UVC showed the diversity of the ichthyofauna to be significantly higher inside the protected area. Interestingly this did not apply to the results of the controlled fishing experiment where the diversity of fish in the catch was lower in the protected area - a result that may be explained by the selectivity of fishing for the most aggressive species – and a reminder of the limitations of controlled fishing experiments. Possibly the most important finding of the study revolved around the benthic community. These were significantly different at exploited and protected sites, with algae and crinoids more abundant at exploited sites. Crinoids are the principle food of roman and were low in abundance where roman abundances were high, suggesting that the dominant top predator reduced crinoids. Furthermore, it substantiates the correlation of roman abundance with fishing effort, since habitat preferences can be ruled out by the observed causal predator-prey distribution pattern. Low algae abundances at protected sites correlated with high strepie (Sarpa salpa) frequencies within the fish communities encountered there. Strepie, a shoaling and abundant benthic grazer, does not compete for food with roman, suggesting a high potential for coexistence of the two species. As expected, and found by other studies, life history traits of roman differed between protected and exploited sample-sites. With a significantly lower age-at-maturity and age-atsex- change, the exploited population showed a typical response to fishing effort. The sex ratio of this protogynous hermaphrodite was found to be sustained at healthy levels by phenotypic plasticity. However, one important additional factor was highlighted by the study; the average condition factor of the protected population was significantly lower (0.0283 g/cm³) compared to the exploited population (0.0295 g/cm³). This was probably due to the higher intra-specific competition for lower food abundance in the protected area. Interestingly the diving and fishing survey methods yielded similar mortality results for roman. Total mortality rate estimates derived from length frequency analysis from the diving and fishing survey were not different (0.32 and 0.29 y⁻¹, respectively) as were natural mortality rate estimates (0.24 and 0.19 y⁻¹, respectively). Natural mortality rate (M) estimates indicated by Pauly’s and Hoenig’s relationship were similar (0.25 and 0.23 y⁻¹, respectively). Detailed yield-per-recruit (Y/R) and spawner biomass-per-recruit (SB/R) analyses were presented for different levels of M, varying age-at-recruitment (tR) and fishing mortality (F). Current tR (7.60 y) and F (0.16 and 0.25 y⁻¹, from the diving and fishing dataset, respectively) suggests an optimal exploitation of the population in the exploited part of the study area. However, a separate SB/R analysis of the male part of the population showed their vulnerability to over-exploitation, even at reduced age-at-sex-change from fishing. There therefore remains a high risk of recruitment failure for the roman population. Of course MPAs can be used to measure stock status directly if the influence of factors such as cachability, habitat and sampling method on CPUE assessments can be limited or reduced. The experimental design in this study allowed for contemporary CPUE comparisons across the border of the Goukamma MPA. Results were similar to those obtained by the SB/R analyses. CPUE extrapolations therefore, using small MPAs, can provide reliable and consistent estimates, and offer a practical alternative to conventional assessment strategies. This study has highlighted the importance of ensuring a well structured and comprehensive survey design when undertaking a comparison of protected and exploited marine areas. The results provide a comprehensive framework for future management of the Goukamma MPA and other protected areas along the temperate coastline of South Africa.

Bibliography: leaves 44-53.
13C/12C and 15N/14N were used to indicate the trophic levels of the shallow-water Cape hake, Merluccius capensis (Castelnau) at three sites on the west coast of South Africa, and five sites on the south coast. Gut content analyses show only the very recent diet of hake, therefore stable carbon and nitrogen isotope ratios were used to show the longer-term diet, integrated over the turnover time of the muscle tissue and bone collagen analysed. 13C/12C is 1-2%₀ higher in the tissues of a consumer than its diet (DeNiro and Epstein 1978), the difference in 15N/14N between a consumer and its food being 3-4%₀ (DeNiro and Epstein 1981). Both 13C/12C and 15N/14N indicate trophic enrichment between hake muscle tissue and bone collagen, and the gut contents and prey, and show that small and large hake feed at different trophic levels, large hake tissues being slightly heavier in 13C than small hake tissues, and containing 2-4%₀ more 15N than muscle tissue and bone collagen, and the gut contents and prey, and show that small and large hake feed at different trophic levels, large hake tissues being slightly heavier in 13C than small hake tissues, and containing 2-4%₀ and more 15N than muscle tissue and bone collagen of small hake.