Academic literature on the topic 'Music for silent film'

Martin Marks holds an almost unique position to talk about silent film music: he is a scholarly musician and musical scholar. Besides his canonical book on the history of silent film music (1997), he has been playing piano accompaniments for silent films regularly for nearly four decades. In this interview we asked Martin about the challenges and complexities of choosing and creating music to accompany musical numbers in silent cinema. Martin relates how he detects musical numbers and he expounds his decision-making process on how to treat them. His explanations are interspersed with engaging examples from his practical work and based on both his scholarly knowledge and on his musical intelligence. He talks about the use of pre-existing music as well as about anachronisms in choosing music written many decades after a film was first released. In sum, this interview delivers detailed and informed insights into the difficulties and pleasures of accompanying musical numbers or other types of diegetic music in silent cinema.

Although the film musical as a genre came into its own with the sound film technologies of the late 1920s and early 1930s, several characteristic features did not originate solely with the sound film. The ‘musical number’ as the epitome of the genre, can already be found in different forms and shapes in silent films. This article looks at two Austrian silent films, Sonnige Träume (1921) and Seine Hoheit, der Eintänzer (1926), as case studies for how music is represented without a fixed sound source, highlighting the differences and similarities of musical numbers in silent and sound films. The chosen films are analysed in the contexts of their historical exhibition and accompaniment practices, Austria’s film industry as well as the country’s cultural-political situation after the end of the monarchy. These two examples demonstrate that several characteristics of the film musical are based on the creative endeavours made by filmmakers during the silent era, who struggled, failed and succeeded in ‘visualizing’ music and musical performances in the so-called ‘silent’ films. In reconstructing their problems and analysing their solutions, we are able to gain a deeper understanding of the nature of musical numbers during the silent era and on a more general level.

Abstract Collections of silent film music constitute valuable sources for historical research on the musical practice in the silent film era. The musical prints preserved in the Mirskey Collection were previously used by the author to reconstruct a score for the movie A Kiss for Cinderella (1925, dir. Herbert Brenon). This article describes the historical context considered during the reconstruction and discusses the workflow applied by Nek Mirskey (Bronisław Mirski) as a musical director of movie theatres. A comparative analysis of sheet music from the Mirskey Collection accompanied by handwritten notes, original cue sheet compiled by James Bradford for the Paramount Pictures, and a digitised copy of the film, have led to conclusions that are applicable not only to Mirskey's methods of compiling scores, but also to the more general rules for the development of musical accompaniments to silent films in the 1920s.

Abstract Bronisław Mirski (b. 1887 as Moszkowicz in Żyrardów near Warsaw, Poland – d. 1927 in El Paso, Texas) belongs to the substantial group of Polish émigré artists of Jewish origin. A violinist and conductor educated in Europe, he permanently settled in the United States at the end of 1914 under the name of Nek Mirskey and soon began working as a music director in movie theatres. He was in charge of the musical settings for elaborate artistic programmes composed of silent films as well as music and stage attractions. His first widely acclaimed shows were presented at the Metropolitan Theatre of Harry M. Crandall's chain in Washington, D.C. Based primarily on the American press of 1921–23, this article discusses Mirski's work methods and his involvement in improving the quality of live musical accompaniment for silent films. The work that he continued till the end of his life places him among the foremost musicians of the silent film era.

Academy Award-winning Austrian screenwriter Walter Reisch’s (1903‐83) career started in Austrian silent cinema and ended in Hollywood. Reisch wrote the screenplays for silent films, many of them based on musical topics (operetta films, biopics of musicians, etc.). He created the so-called Viennese film, a musical subgenre, set in an almost mythological Vienna. In my article I am analysing the characteristics of his writing in which music plays a crucial part. The article details the use of musical devices in his screenplays (his use of music, the influence of musical melodrama, instructions and use of songs and leitmotifs). The article closes with a reading of the final number in the last film he was able to make in Austria: Silhouetten (1936).

Abstract This article examines a series of lawsuits that consumed Italy’s legal establishment between approximately 1924 and 1933. Resulting from a protracted labor dispute between instrumental musicians who worked in cinemas and the exhibitors who employed them, the lawsuits turned on a question of employment law: whether musicians ought to be considered full-time employees—entitled to various benefits and protections against unfair termination—or more precariously situated freelancers whom exhibitors could hire and fire at will. As a consequence of the vagaries of existing Italian labor law and new Fascist legislation governing labor relations, musicians were already at a disadvantage in this dispute. Unexpectedly, their situation was further undermined by the judiciary, as Italy’s highest court made their employee status conditional on the perceived aesthetic value of cinema and its associated music making. That is, musicians had to prove that their musical abilities were integral to the artistic outcome of any given film screening—a tall order in the context of silent cinematic exhibition, where musical accompaniment was materially distinct from the projected film. Precisely because the courts valorized the fusion of music and image, however, the Italian musicians’ lawsuits illuminate a fundamental parameter of cinematic aesthetics—synchronization—and reveal something significant about the nature of film music. Public recognition for effecting music-image synchronization in film conferred symbolic, but also literal, capital; thus I contend that synchronization ought to be understood as a form of musical labor, both in the silent era and beyond.

AbstractIn July 1922, the New York Times reported that the “encouraging little film” Danse Macabre was screening at the Rialto Theater in New York City. Directed by filmmaker Dudley Murphy, it starred dancers Adolph Bolm and Ruth Page in a visual interpretation of Saint-Saëns's Danse Macabre that synchronized perfectly with live performances of the composition. While film scholars have occasionally cited Danse Macabre and Murphy's other shorts from this period as examples of early avant-garde filmmaking in the United States, discussions of the films are mired in misunderstanding. In this article, I use advertisements, reviews, and other archival materials to trace the production, exhibition, and reception of Murphy's Visual Symphony project. These films, I argue, were not Murphy's alone: rather, they were a collaborative endeavor guided as heavily by musician and film exhibitor Hugo Riesenfeld as by Murphy himself. Recast in this way, the Visual Symphony project highlights evolving approaches to sound–image synchronization in the 1920s, the centrality of theater conductors and musicians to filmmaking in this period, and the various ways in which filmmakers, performers, and exhibitors conceptualized the relationship between music and film, and the live and the mediated, in the final decade of the silent era.

Film's attraction to opera began not with the technical possibility of synchronising the operatic voice with the image, but earlier, in the silent era. In the New York Times of 27 August 1910 Thomas Edison declared: ‘We'll be ready for the moving picture shows in a couple of months, but I'm not satisfied with that. I want to give grand opera.’ What did silent film seek in opera? Would a silent film of or about opera have any meaning? What are the possibilities for silent opera? How would a mute operatic voice appear in film?

Film d'Art, the French production company responsible for the development of Henri Lavédan's L'Assassinat du Duc de Guise (1908), demonstrated a forward-thinking vision for film and music. Through their innovations, the company combined many elements of cinematography with new standards for quality productions. This project report will investigate the goals of Film d'Art and its unusually high ambitions, standard music practices in the silent film era, the issues revolving around the instrumentation to Saint-Saëns' score to Henri Lavédan's L'Assassinat de Duc de Guise (1908), and the performance of my arrangement in a graduate recital.

The Basilica Notre-Dame Choir accompanying screenings of The Hunchback of Notre Dame at the Regent in 1924, imaginative community prologues before Mary Pickford’s Pollyanna at the Russell in 1920, and costumed opera soloists singing alongside the showing of The Bohemian Girl at the Imperial in 1926: the history of Ottawa’s silent cinemas is an exciting mix of film, theatre, technology, music, and community. Unfortunately, Ottawa’s musical history in the early 1900s has been, by and large, forgotten, and local cinema histories are relatively sparse. In much the same manner that Ottawa theatres incorporated both North American and local elements into their programming, this thesis demonstrates that an examination of the musicians of local cinemas can not only provide information to understand the development of silent film music practices in general, but also unveil a network of musicians and a series of important histories. This thesis reconstructs parts of Ottawa’s silent film music history using a number of methodologies (digital research, archival research, and social network mapping) and primary sources (IATSE union documents, Department of Labour strike documents, newspapers, and trade journals). It also analyses several screenings where music and film were uniquely combined and introduces key figures in Ottawa’s silent film music scene (including violinist Rudolph Pelisek and organist Amédée Tremblay), showing how their training provided prestige to cinemas and how their involvement in military, religious, and communal activities added to cinemas’ appeal. ----- Le Chœur de la Basilique Notre-Dame accompagnant les présentations du film The Hunchback of Notre Dame au Regent en 1924, les prologues communautaires inventifs avant le Pollyanna de Mary Pickford au Russell en 1920, et les soloistes d’opéra chantant à côté de la projection de The Bohemian Girl à l’Imperial en 1926: l’histoire des cinémas muets d’Ottawa est un mélange excitant de film, théâtre, technologie, musique et communauté. Malheureusement, le passé musical d’Ottawa au début du vingtième siècle a été largement oublié, et les histoires locales du cinéma sont relativement rares. De la même façon que les théâtres d’Ottawa incluaient à la fois des éléments locaux et nord-américains dans leur programmation, cette thèse démontre qu’un examen des musiciens des cinémas locaux peut non seulement procurer des renseignements pour comprendre le développement de la musique du cinéma muet en général, mais encore lever le voile sur un réseau de musiciens et une série de récits d’importance. Cette thèse reconstruit des aspects de l’histoire de la musique du du cinéma muet à Ottawa en utilisant un plusieurs méthodologies (la recherche numérique, la recherche en archives, et la cartographie des réseaux sociaux) et de sources primaires (documents du syndicat ouvrier IATSE, documents de grève du ministère fédéral du Travail, quotidiens, et revues spécialisées). La thèse analyse aussi quelques instances uniques de combinaison de musique et de film, et présente des personnages clé de la scène musicale du cinéma muet d’Ottawa (incluant le violoniste Rudolph Pelisek et l’organiste Amédée Tremblay), tout en montrant comment leur formation procurait du prestige aux cinémas, et comment leur implication dans des activités militaires, religieuses, et communautaires ont ajouté à la popularité des cinémas.

This thesis argues that how-to manuals and cue sheets are indicative of ideal performance practice amongst musicians from the silent film era. Pre-scored music was widely practiced amongst musicians. How-to manuals and cue sheets helped the musician accurately and consistently accompany a film. Authors of period manuals include W. Tyacke George, Edith Lang and George West, Ernst Luz and George Tootell. Compilers of cue sheet include James C. Bradford, Ernst Luz, Edward Kilenyi and Michael P. Krueger. Cue by cue analyses of The Cat and the Canary and The Gaucho show a high repetition of music, establishing continuity between the music played and the image on the screen. This shows how compilers associated music and film. These manuals and cue sheets prove that the musician community strove for a close connection between the image on screen and accompaniment. By 1920, arbitrary improvisation was unacceptable.

The thesis examines ’intermediality’ in Svenska Bios (Swedish Biograph) first fiction films. Värmlänningarne (1910), Fänrik Ståls Sägner (1910), Bröllopet på Ulfåsa (1910), Regina von Emmeritz och Konung Gustaf II Adolf (1910), Amuletten (1910), Emigranten (1910) and Järnbäraren (1911) are analysed in relation to theatre, literature, music and ‘reality’. A detailed discussion of intermediality is combined with specific theories relating to pictorialism and literary presentation in film. The thesis conclude, that early fiction films in general, and Svenska Bios films in particular, depended on their association with other media. The thesis also includes a short discussion concerning silent cinema music.

Ce travail étudie le rapport entre le langage narratif cinématographique et le discours musical contemporain. Le point de départ en a été l’étude des nouvelles créations contemporaines écrites pour accompagner certains films de l’époque du cinéma muet. Pour atteindre ces objectifs, nous sommes partis d’une vision théorique, pour arriver à l’analyse plus concrète qui nous a donné les consignes de base pour créer notre propre modèle d’analyse applicable à la composition. Ce modèle permet de préciser les concepts nous permettant d´aborder la relation entre le film et la musique selon deux axes, que nous appelons respectivement « points d’ancrage » (qui traitent des points d’articulation du discours cinématographique avec la musique) et « points de référence » (qui gèrent les éléments formels du discours cinématographique et musical). Dans la dernière partie de ce travail, nous appliquons notre modèle à la réalisation de quatre projets personnels, qui représentent une « conclusion artistique » des éléments analysés au cours de cette recherche
This work studies the relationship between the film’s narrative language and the contemporary music speech. The starting point of this work is the study of the new contemporary scores, which were composed for silent films from the 1920’s onwards. To reach these goals, we started from a theoretical vision, to subsequently perform a practical analysis. This gave us the important points to create our analysis model to be used for music composition. This model allows us to clarify the relationship between the film and the music, based on two main axes: the “anchoring points” (giving us the articulation points between the music and the film) and the “reference points” (which deals with the formal elements of both film and music speech). In the last part of our work, we have applied our model to the composition of four personal projects, which were created as an artistic conclusion of our research

The fact that silent cinema is not to be considered just as a precursor to sound cinema, in an evolutionary sense, is today well acknowledged. The studies of scholars such as Tom Gunning, André Gaudreault, Richard Abel, Noël Burch and Charles Musser have moreover invited to consider what the “silent era” harbored not just as another cinema than the “sound” one, but as a number of “other” ways to conceive cinema, each one of them needing an accurately different approach, whatever is the chosen perspective (historiographical, aesthetic, sociologic, etc.) to look at them from. However, it is strange how one of these perspectives seems to be reluctant in accepting this awareness towards the silent production. It is the musical perspective: even if studies that deal with silent film music according to the specific features of the different languages of the silents have been developed indeed (most notably, the ones by Rick Altman), they nonetheless remain a minority. The panorama of discourses about film music, as of 2010, can still include authoritative contributions saying that «almost nothing has changed from the beginnings to present days» in the general way in which music interacts with moving images. Signs of this attitude are to be found even in the field of film preservation. Film archives devoted to silents, in fact, do not often accompany their film collections with pertinent music collections. There are, of course, meaningful exceptions, like the silent music collections at the Library of Congress or at the MoMA, or the Eyl/Van Houten Collection at the Nederlands Filmmuseum. But they are, precisely, exceptions. This situation apparently clashes with the need for «painstaking historical research» that Rick Altman recommends to be at the core of contemporary studies on silent films. A research done within an archive of silent film, in fact, is likely to be incomplete on the side of music and sound practices. Musicians of the silent era interacted with films by staying at the side of the screen, in the shadows next to the light of the projector: it is quite ironic how the discourse on their music, now, is again confined in a “shadow” – a metaphoric one, though - which borders with the “light” of the modern studies on silent cinema, but cannot proficiently interact with it. «It is time», as Altman said, «to include sound in silent cinema’s historiographical revival». A complete silent film music archive should be at the interface between a music library and a performing arts collection. Written scores, during the silent era, were a minority: the greatest part of the musical practice was instead based on cue sheets, compilations, repertoires, or even improvisations –which cannot of course have left any trace outside occasional accounts from audience members or the performers themselves. Moreover, practices of non-musical sonorization where often complementary to and concurrent with music performances: so, there is an evident need to keep record of them too. In addition to that, it must be remembered that, especially since the 1980 Thames Television presentation of Abel Gance’s Napoléon, reconstructed by Kevin Brownlow with new music by Carl Davis, the repertoire of the music for the silents started to grow again. In the last 30 years, the venues where silent film are screened in a way respectful of historical practices multiplied, as well as the production of appropriate music accompaniments founded on complete scores, but also, again, on cue sheets and improvisations, just like during the actual silent age. It seems reasonable for this “new” tradition of music for silents to be preserved alongside the historical documents which are its origin and source of inspiration. My Ph. D. thesis uses these considerations as a premise to reconstruct and study a special and circumscribed collection of silent film music: the repertoire played at the international silent film festival Le Giornate del Cinema Muto from 1982 to present days. The accuracy shown by this festival in the presentation and divulgation of silent film music practices provides in fact a solid ground for a project of this kind. In addition to that, Le Giornate have already expressed, in 2009, the intention of having such an archive developed in Pordenone, after a suggestion I advanced during the XI Collegium organized by the festival. The thesis is divided into two parts. The first one includes an introductory chapter, where problems about the archival preservation of musical sources pertinent to silent film music are discussed; then, a first chapter deals with an outline of the history of music for silent films, choosing a non-linear approach based on the insurgence of musical practices more than on a chronological succession; finally, the first part is concluded by a chapter describing the aesthetic of music for silent films, comprehensive of a review of the pertinent literature and a description of the audiovisual strategies used by the composers. The second part is the repertoire of the music that has been performed live at Le Giornate del Cinema Muto on the basis of written scores. 115 films are listed following the 29 editions of the Festival, with full filmographic information. Each film is accompanied by a short analysis of the main audiovisual strategies. The sources of this research are mainly the audiovisual recordings of the screenings at le Giornate del Cinema Muto preserved at La Cineteca del Friuli, Gemona. Other details have been collected through conversations (in person or via email) with some of the authors of the music: Gillian B. Anderson, Neil Brand, Günter A. Buchwald, Philip Carli, Antonio Coppola, Berndt Heller, Stephen Horne, Maud Nelissen, Donald Sosin and Gabriel Thibaudeau.
Il fatto che il cinema muto non possa essere considerato un mero precursore del cinema sonoro, secondo una logica «biologica e teleologica», è oggi ampiamente riconosciuto. Le riflessioni di studiosi quali Tom Gunning, André Gaudreault, Richard Abel, Noël Burch e Charles Musser hanno inoltre invitato a considerare il muto non solo come un altro cinema rispetto al sonoro, ma come un sistema di pratiche cinematografiche concorrenti ed essenzialmente diverse da quella del sonoro, decisamente mal raccolte sotto l’etichetta generica “cinema muto”. Ciascuna di queste maniere cinematografiche, numerose e dall’identificazione e denominazione controversa– cinematografia-attrazione, cinema dei primi tempi, cinema primitivo, ecc. – necessita di distinti strumenti d’analisi, quale che sia il punto di vista (storiografico, estetico, sociologico, ecc.) scelto per studiarla. È tuttavia strano come uno di questi possibili punti di vista si stia ancor oggi dimostrando piuttosto riluttante nell’accettare tale genere di consapevolezza nei confronti del muto. Si tratta del punto di vista musicale. È vero che non sono mancati gli studi teorici capaci di trattare la musica per il cinema muto tenendo conto della molteplicità e delle differenti necessità dei linguaggi visivi di quell’epoca: Rick Altman ha in particolare offerto alcune delle riflessioni più interessanti in tal senso. Ma tali riflessioni sono rimaste una minoranza. Il panorama dei discorsi sulla musica per film nel 2010 è ancora in grado di accogliere contributi importanti che tuttavia non differenziano le strategie audiovisive del sonoro da quelle del muto, sostenendo che nella maniera generale in cui la musica interagisce con l’immagine in movimento «poco o nulla è cambiato dalle origini ad oggi». Segni di questa tendenza si riscontrano persino nell’ambito della preservazione dei film. Gli archivi cinematografici attivi nella conservazione del muto, infatti, raramente accompagnano le loro collezioni con archivi paralleli destinati alla documentazione relativa alla musica. Esiste, bisogna riconoscere, la consapevolezza dell’importanza che i documenti musicali possono avere nelle operazioni di restauro e preservazione dei film. Esistono inoltre casi particolari di raccolte di musica per il muto gestite in sinergia con archivi di film, come le collezioni di musica per il muto conservate alla Library of Congress di Washington, DC, o al Museum of Modern Arts (MoMA) di New York, oppure la Eyl/Van Houten Collection presso il Nederlands Filmmuseum. Ma si tratta di eccezioni: e fino alla fine degli anni ’80 in effetti non esistevano significative raccolte di musica per il cinema muto al di fuori di quella del MoMA. Questo stato delle cose sembra in apparente contrasto con la necessità di una «ricerca storica coscienziosa» che Altman raccomanda parlando dell’approccio contemporaneo al muto. Infatti, allo stato attuale delle cose, una ricerca sul muto svolta in un singolo archivio rischia plausibilmente di essere molto carente sul versante delle pratiche sonore e musicali. Durante l’epoca del muto, i musicisti interagivano con i film restando accanto allo schermo, nell’ombra vicina alla luce del proiettore. È piuttosto ironico come oggi i discorsi sviluppati attorno alla loro musica siano nuovamente costretti in un’“ombra” – metaforica, stavolta – che sta ai confini della “luce” costituita dai moderni studi sul cinema muto, senza però poter ben interagire con essa. «È tempo», come ha scritto Altman, «di includere il suono nella rinascita storiografica del cinema muto». Un archivio della musica per il cinema muto dovrebbe porsi all’intersezione tra una biblioteca musicale ed una collezione di materiali legati alle arti performative. Le partiture scritte, durante l’epoca del muto, erano infatti una minoranza: la maggior parte della pratica musicale si fondava su cue sheet, compilazioni, repertori o improvvisazioni – che non possono aver lasciato alcuna traccia al di fuori di occasionali resoconti di membri del pubblico o degli stessi musicisti. In più, pratiche di sonorizzazione non musicali erano spesso concomitanti e complementari alle esecuzioni: esiste dunque una chiara urgenza di preservare anche qualsiasi tipo di documentazione parli di esse. In aggiunta a ciò, occorre ricordare che, almeno dalla presentazione del 1980 del Napoleon di Abel Gance prodotta da Thames Television, che ha mostrato il film ricostruito da Kevin Brownlow con una nuova musica di Carl Davis, il repertorio della musica per il muto ha cominciato a crescere di nuovo. Negli ultimi trent’anni, i luoghi dove i film muti vengono proiettati in maniera rispettosa di pratiche musicali storiche si sono moltiplicati, assieme alla produzione di partiture, cue sheet e improvvisazioni. Sembra ragionevole offrire a questa “nuova” tradizione di musica per il muto un posto accanto ai documenti che ne sono origine ed ispirazione. La mia tesi di dottorato utilizza queste considerazioni come premessa per ricostruire e studiare una collezione particolare e circoscritta di musica per il cinema muto: il repertorio di partiture eseguite al Festival internazionale Le Giornate del Cinema Muto, dal 1982 al 2010. L’accuratezza filologica dimostrata da tale Festival nella presentazione e nella divulgazione delle pratiche musicali del muto offre infatti una solida base per studi di questo genere. Inoltre, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto hanno già espresso, nel 2009, l’intenzione di fondare concretamente un archivio come quello sopra descritto, in seguito ad un suggerimento da me avanzato nel corso del XI Collegium di studi organizzato dalla manifestazione. La tesi è divisa in due parti. La prima include un capitolo introduttivo, dove vengono discussi problemi riguardanti la conservazione archivistica delle fonti musicali pertinenti alla musica per il muto; dopodiché, un primo capitolo tratta della storia della musica per il muto, scegliendo un approccio non lineare guidato dallo sviluppo delle pratiche musicali, e non da una consequenzialità cronologica; infine, la prima parte si conclude con un capitolo descrivente l’estetica della musica per il muto, nel quale si offre una rassegna della letteratura sull’argomento ed una descrizione delle strategie audiovisive utilizzate dai compositori. La seconda parte presenta il repertorio della musica che è stata eseguita a Le Giornate del Cinema Muto sulla base di partiture scritte. Si tratta di un elenco di 115 film, coprente la 29 edizioni del Festival e completo di informazioni filmografiche. Ogni scheda di film è accompagnata da una breve analisi delle principali strategie audiovisive. Le fonti di questa ricerca sono principalmente le registrazioni audiovisive delle proiezioni a Le Giornate del Cinema Muto conservate presso La Cineteca del Friuli, Gemona. Altri dettagli si sono ottenuti tramite conversazioni (di persona o tramite email) con alcuni degli autori delle musiche: Gillian B. Anderson, Neil Brand, Günter A. Buchwald, Philip Carli, Antonio Coppola, Berndt Heller, Stephen Horne, Maud Nelissen, Donald Sosin e Gabriel Thibaudeau.

The History of Horn Playing in Los Angeles from 1920 to 1970 begins with the horn players who played in the silent film orchestras and the Alfred Brain's tenure with the Los Angeles Philharmonic. This study details the introduction of soundtracks, the early studio orchestras, the contract studio orchestras, the musician union's role in structuring the work environment, the horn players who played in both the Los Angeles Philharmonic and the studios, major figures from the subsequent freelance period such as Vincent de Rosa, and the local and international influence of the Los Angeles Horn Club.

The Canadian contribution and data set prepared as part of the Global Media and Internet Concentration (GMIC) project offers an independent academic, empirical and data-driven analysis of a deceptively simple yet profoundly important question: have telecom, media and internet markets become more concentrated over time, or less? Media Ownership and Concentration is presented from more than a dozen sectors of the telecom-media-internet industries, including film, music and book industries.

Bendigo, where the traditional owners are the Dja Dja Wurrung people, has capitalised on its European historical roots. Its striking architecture owes much to its Gold Rush past which has also given it a diverse cultural heritage. The creative industries, while not well recognised as such, contribute well to the local economy. The many festivals, museums and library exhibitions attract visitors from the metropolitan centre of Victoria especially. The Bendigo Creative Industries Hub was a local council initiative while the Ulumbarra Theatre is located within the City’s 1860’s Sandhurst Gaol. Many festivals keep the city culturally active and are supported by organisations such as Bendigo Bank. The Bendigo Writers Festival, the Bendigo Queer Film Festival, The Bendigo Invention & Innovation Festival, Groovin the Moo and the Bendigo Blues and Roots Music Festival are well established within the community. A regional accelerator and Tech School at La Trobe University are touted as models for other regional Victorian cities. The city has a range of high quality design agencies, while the software and digital content sector is growing with embeddeds working in agriculture and information management systems. Employment in Film, TV and Radio and Visual Arts has remained steady in Bendigo for a decade while the Music and Performing Arts sector grew quite well over the same period.

The Sunshine Coast (unless otherwise specified, Sunshine Coast refers to the region which includes both Sunshine Coast and Noosa council areas) is a classic regional hotspot. In many respects, the Sunshine Coast has assets that make it the “Goldilocks” of Queensland hotspots: “the agility of the region and our collaborative nature is facilitated by the fact that we're not too big, not too small - 330,000 people” (Paddenburg, 2019); “We are in that perfect little bubble of just right of about everything” (Erbacher 2019). The Sunshine Coast has one of the fastest-growing economies in Australia. Its population is booming and its local governments are working together to establish world-class communications, transport and health infrastructure, while maintaining the integrity of the region’s much-lauded environment and lifestyle. As a result, the Sunshine Coast Council is regarded as a pioneer on smart city initiatives, while Noosa Shire Council has built a reputation for prioritising sustainable development. The region’s creative economy is growing at a faster rate that of the rest of the economy—in terms of job growth, earnings, incomes and business registrations. These gains, however, are not spread uniformly. Creative Services (that is, the advertising and marketing, architecture and design, and software and digital content sectors) are flourishing, while Cultural Production (music and performing arts, publishing and visual arts) is variable, with visual and performing arts growing while film, television and radio and publishing have low or no growth. The spirit of entrepreneurialism amongst many creatives in the Sunshine Coast was similar to what we witnessed in other hotspots: a spirit of not necessarily relying on institutions, seeking out alternative income sources, and leveraging networks. How public agencies can better harness that energy and entrepreneurialism could be a focus for ongoing strategy. There does seem to be a lower level of arts and culture funding going into the Sunshine Coast from governments than its population base and cultural and creative energy might suggest. Federal and state arts funding programs are under-delivering to the Sunshine Coast.